[Masthead] Overcast ~ 64°F  
High: 71°F ~ Low: 58°F
Saturday, May 25, 2013

Is Congress saying no to bake sales?

Posted Friday, January 21, 2011, at 9:49 AM

(Photo)
It's a fundraising staple - the Bake Sale. It doesn't matter what you're selling for, a bake sale will always do good. I mean anybody can go and buy a $2 brownie at a grocery store, but will it taste as good as Mrs. Smith's homemade double fudge extra large size brownie? There has been much debate on Capital Hill however on the "healthiness" of bake sales.

It's no secret that childhood obesity is the "agenda" of first lady Michelle Obama. She's constantly on the Disney channel with messages about exercising and eating right. Her and the president have even dared to call their daughters "over weight" in some interviews. Whether she was the driving force in this 220 page bill known as the "Healthy, Hunger Free Kids Act of 2010" or a congress that wants to have healthcare under the care of the government, it shows that the government, thinks we have to define what an American is, should act like and should look like. I've said it in previous posts - the government doesn't want to care for fat people in their new health insurance plan - this is one of the many steps they see to control us to be skinny.

Basically my understanding of the bill is that bake sales, pizza fundraisers, pie fundraisers, cookie dough etc. are okay because they are after school and not on school grounds. But anything that is during school hours and on school grounds can be considered to fattening to feed the children. This includes vending machines, and there is also language in the bill of what type of milk should be offered, so pop machines and juice machines may get nixed also. I don't know if they still do it, but when I was in high school a cooking class learned how to make doughnuts and would sell them in the morning a couple times a year - no more doughnuts under this bill.

Which does bring the question, how will this affect our schools breakfast program? Throughout the month of January you can have a couple different types of donuts, pop-tarts, and muffins. Do these technically fit nutritional standards? But then again, why can't we let our kids, in a controlled setting (which school is) eat a food because they enjoy it? After all, since these bake sales are only regulated during school hours the kids have to bring the money to enjoy the food, so it's probably money they saved or worked for. Is that not a good life lesson to teach - that money you saved or worked for can be spent as you deem fit, but when it's gone, it's gone?

The next question is how long is it going to be before Congress says any food on school grounds should meet health requirements because kids at basketball games are getting fat from the pizza? That the after school fundraisers of cookie dough and pies allow fattening foods to be brought into children's homes and they could become obese?

I have no problem with the government helping to provide healthier meals to the children of the United States, especially in some places where these are the only meals these children might get. I do however have a problem with saying no to the occassional Mrs. Smith's oversized over chocolatey ooey gooey brownie, because like girl scout cookies, I get once a year to look forward to it.

For anyone that is looking for the specific language of the bill in question here, it can be found at the link above and the wording is found on page 98 starting with lines one through six - (B) APPLICATION.--The nutrition standards shall apply to all foods sold-- ''(i) outside the school meal programs; ''(ii) on the school campus; and ''(iii) at any time during the school day. and page 99, lines three through ten: ''(IV) special exemptions for school-sponsored fundraisers (other than fundraising through vending machines, school stores, snack bars, a la carte sales, and any other exclusions determined by the Secretary), if the fundraisers are approved by the school and are infrequent within the school."


Comments
Showing comments in chronological order
[Show most recent comments first]

"special exemptions for school-sponsored fundraisers (other than fundraising through vending machines, school stores, snack bars, a la carte sales, and any other exclusions determined by the Secretary)"

I as big of a fan of childhood obesity and diabetes as the next person, but I think that part I just quoted says the opposite of your headline.

As far as saying no more bake sales, the bill allows for the USDA to set nutritional guidelines. Guidelines that won't even be set for another year. Nobody has banned anything.

The right wing blogs have been stoking fears about this bill, prompting USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack to issue a letter into the public record.

Vilsack wrote:

"The USDA agrees with and respects the intent of Congress to permit exemptions for school approved fundraisers -- including bake sales or other occasional or infrequent fundraisers.

With respect to concessions at sporting events, depending on the particular school schedule, the majority of these events would likely fall outside of the school day, and thus beyond the authority granted by the bill. Again, USDA has no intention of going further than the Congressional directive on this issue."

Once the legislation is signed into law by President Obama, USDA has a year to write the new nutritional guidelines for school foods. There's no looming, pandemic ban on sweets being sold at fundraisers, in part because that public comment period will likely generate loads of fodder for the USDA to chew on. The USDA will announce the public comment period soon, according to a spokesman.

A summary of the new legislation is here.

http://ag.senate.gov/site/legislation.ht...

-- Posted by TJ Templeton on Mon, Jan 24, 2011, at 11:09 AM

TJ- I changed the headline for the third time, because you are right, it was more of a misleading statement before. However, posed as a question, I think it draws in the readers and if they read the blog, can come to their own conclusions. If you read the sentinel's article about the local schools changes to the menu however you will notice they have to cut back on a lot of their menu.

-- Posted by BKinney on Mon, Jan 24, 2011, at 11:27 AM

Gee, how nice. The government will give us little people the opportunity to possibly eat what we want to, when we want to. It's that so special of them?

Does this apply to all school food programs? What about private schools? Does the government control those too? Maybe even, home schools?

If they do, then don't they control what any person, to include parents, feed children? I wonder how long it will be till parents have to submit the week's family menu to government for approval?

Maybe there ought just be government feeding stations for the people. No food is allowed outside the government programs.

Isn't big government silly? I think so too.

-- Posted by a777pilot on Mon, Jan 24, 2011, at 4:09 PM

I think the government needs to goes on a spending diet first.

Clay Boggess

http://www.bigeventfundraising.com

-- Posted by clayboggess on Wed, Feb 2, 2011, at 9:20 AM

Sorry, 'goes' should be 'go'

-- Posted by clayboggess on Wed, Feb 2, 2011, at 9:22 AM


Respond to this blog

Posting a comment requires free registration. If you already have an account, enter your username and password below. Otherwise, click here to register.

Username:

Password:  (Forgot your password?)

Your comments:
Please be respectful of others and try to stay on topic.


Made In America
Becky Kinney
Recent posts
Archives
Blog RSS feed [Feed icon]
Comments RSS feed [Feed icon]
Login
I started blogging about my fun experiencing parenthood and have found it has evolved into more than just parenting - its an observation of life as we know it. I'm a bystander in this country just as we all are, and sometimes, opinions just need to be said without fear of being burnt at the stake.
Hot topics
Teenage Lessons: Actions have Consequences
(0 ~ 10:54 AM, Apr 5)

Are we too overprotective of our children?
(0 ~ 10:07 AM, Mar 6)

We are an imperfect society
(6 ~ 12:53 PM, Dec 26)

Careful what you wish for
(0 ~ 5:44 PM, Jul 29)

Arts vs. Sports in Schools
(0 ~ 8:15 AM, Apr 6)