|
|
|
|
|
Partly Cloudy ~ High: 84°F ~ Low: 65°F Saturday, May 18, 2013 |
|
Clark or Kissinger? That is the questionPosted Wednesday, January 27, 2010, at 9:23 AM
Much debate has come over the past couple of years of whether to close Kissinger Elementary or take classes out of Clark Elementary. Now that the question has become "the great debate" parents, teachers, students and community members have been forced to take a close look at the issue.
Logically, it makes sense to close Kissinger, you have less students attending and you have more traveling expenses then you do with Clark. But other than the logic, every road points to keeping Kissinger open, even if it means taking classes out of Clark. It is by no means an easy decision for the LCS school board to make, and nor should it be, because it will affect everyone in the LCS district, not just Clark or Kissinger families. From the comments posted on the Daily Sentinel website, it seems like the general consensus around Le Mars is an enthusiastic, "CLOSE KISSINGER!" The main reasons? For the logical reasons listed above and it would be a major inconvience for parents to send their children down there because it's SO far away and then their children would have to ride the bus and that just's one more hassle. Down south in Merrill, they're worried about their kids assimilating with the Le Mars group, the bussing, their property taxes and values, class sizes and well, their town. Can it survive without a school? One thing that parents at all of LCS elementary families should be thinking right now is, "What would I feel like if I were in the other one's shoes?" I believe most people's thoughts would be, "It can't be my school, so it has to be the other one!" As we get older, whether we'd like to admit it or not, we are less open to change, myself included. However this question cannot be avoided any longer and there is a long list of pros and cons on every elementary and school in LCS. Losing any one of these schools is like losing an identity. You can no longer say, "I went to this school" because it's not there. You can't call it, you can't mail something to it, it's gone, pure and simple gone. In twenty years the kids that will be part of LCS will wonder why all these people talk about going to Merrill to school. However, it is easy to write off a school if you were never affiliated with it. The matter gets further complicated because this is just not any school they're thinking about cutting, it's the only one that lies outside the town of Le Mars. The city of Merrill has recently begun to grow and get back on the map, but removal of the school could help collapse the fragile economy that is there. City of Merrill aside, there is also the housing of the special needs children at this school. Some of these kids depend on schedules and conformity and moving them to a totally different bigger school with different kids (most of them will move to Kluckhohn, in the proposal) may upset the balance they have come to known. I'm sure they will take longer to adjust to it then the other kids that will be transferred. On the other side though you have ESL students at Clark that with less classes may not get all the help they need because there's more students and less teachers. And some of their kids are moving to other schools because of classes being taken out too. And then you also have empty classrooms (which are now being used for other purposes according to Mr. Horken). In the end it is up to us parents to convince our children, whether we agree with the school board or not, that the school they will be going to next year is a great school. If we let our disagreements show to our children they may not assimilate as well as they should. What the school board needs to do is have the parents of any school visit each facility to assure them that they all have families, fun and learning. Have the PTO's meet together, have the kids tour the schools before next year, basically unite instead of divide. So please, the next time you think about this decision, do not be so hasty, be open for change, and just remember, "What would you do if you were in the other schools shoes?" Comments Showing comments in chronological order [Show most recent comments first] |
I started blogging about my fun experiencing parenthood and have found it has evolved into more than just parenting - its an observation of life as we know it. I'm a bystander in this country just as we all are, and sometimes, opinions just need to be said without fear of being burnt at the stake.
Hot topics Teenage Lessons: Actions have Consequences(0 ~ 10:54 AM, Apr 5)
Are we too overprotective of our children?
We are an imperfect society
Careful what you wish for
Arts vs. Sports in Schools
|
Couldn't have said it better.
I'm okay with the empathy.
But really? We want the Board to discount the logic? Empathy will cost us an extra $162,000 each year.
I did think about many of these aspects and agreed that a school should be closed. I don't have the connection of a student involved so am looking at this from a different angle. It is a cost savings, and yes an inconvenience. One thing that you failed to mention is that Merrill doesn't have a jr High or High school so these students would need to assimilate anyway eventually. It is a change. It is a challenge. It is a best proposal so far economically. I don't think it has much to do with their economy or home valuations. Does it make Struble resident's home values less because they are bussed?
OnlyMy2Cents - I just wanted to get people thinking and to understand why this isn't a cut a dried issue. The school definitely has to fix a problem that was started years ago and amplified by the government. If that's Merrill, that's what it has to be. But it's better to be proactive vs. reactive in situations like these and there's nothing wrong with going down fighting.
ADifferentView - The difference with Merrill is the draw to having your kid walk to school and/or be close to home. Yes they will be bussed eventually, but they will also be older then. Some parents prefer that. I was a country kid so bussing is not an issue to me either way. You take away the school, you won't get as many people to move there. Even the mayor said that is what happened after LCS pulled the high school from there. Not to mention that when Merrill joined LCS instead of Hinton, the agreement was to keep the elementary open.
ok I am one that had to move to a new school where I did not know anyone when old Central closed. I am great today and strong because of it. The kids from Kissinger will have to one day go to the middle school were there are more kids there. You can't shelter the kids all the time and I feel that is what is going on at Kissinger. All childern must understand each other disabilities and when they are sheltered in Kissinger its really helping no one because the kids with no disability will have no interaction with the kids that are disabled. All kids have challeges and sheltering them is not helping them!
It is a hard call to make and isn't an easy answer. i always thought Clark should have been closed but it had upgrades and is bigger. There are a lot of little issues that really aren't so little to those it affects.
It seems easy to say close Kissenger if you have never dealt with them. My daughter had some reading problems and was sent from Kluckholn to Kissenger. I can't believe how the small classes helped her. The teachers were great. I understand it would save some costs but Hinton is not that far from Merrill either. How many parents would pull their kids from the LeMars schools to send them there and how much lost money would that make?